American cooking Recipes & regional stories

Skillet & Sage

A culinary journey through the fifty states

The regional table / New Hampshire

New England Boiled Dinner

Published September 23, 2026 · New Hampshire

A platter of sliced corned beef surrounded by potatoes, carrots, turnip chunks and cabbage wedges, with a separate bowl of dark red beets beside it
The beets are in their own dish for a reason. Cooked in the pot they turn everything else the same pink. AI-generated illustration.
Jump to Recipe

The cooking is an afternoon of doing nothing. The part worth understanding happened weeks earlier, in a barrel, and the government wrote it down.

The dish is corned beef and root vegetables boiled in one pot, and there is not much to it once the beef is corned. That is where the documents are. Farmers' Bulletin 1415, Beef on the Farm: Slaughtering, Cutting, Curing, published by the United States Department of Agriculture in 1924, gives the whole of it under the heading Curing Beef. Salt, sugar and saltpeter are the three, and it says what each one does: salt "cures the meat and extracts water from the tissues, tending to make it hard and dry"; the action of saltpeter "is similar to that of salt, but in addition gives the meat a reddish or pink color"; sugar "softens the harshness of the salt and improves the flavor of the meat". The numbers are as plain. Cut the beef in pieces five or six inches square, weigh it, allow 8 pounds of salt to every 100 pounds of meat, pack it in alternate layers with the salt in a scoured barrel or stone jar, let it stand overnight, then pour over a solution of 4 pounds of sugar, 2 ounces of baking soda and 4 ounces of saltpeter dissolved in a gallon of lukewarm water, add three gallons more water, and weight the meat under the brine, because any piece that projects spoils the whole. Twenty-eight to forty days. If the brine goes ropy in the spring, scrub every piece with hot water and a stiff brush and start again with new brine. The revision of that literature still in print forty years later, Farmers' Bulletin 2209, Slaughtering, Cutting, and Processing Beef on the Farm, 1966, changes almost nothing: 8 to 10 pounds of salt, the same 4 pounds of sugar and 4 ounces of saltpeter in four gallons of water, thirty to forty days, and a warning that the brine turns ropy if the temperature rises much above 38°F.

The colour that saltpeter fixes is still the legal point of the stuff. The federal table of permitted curing agents at 9 CFR 424.21 lists sodium or potassium nitrate as a "source of nitrite" and sodium or potassium nitrite with its purpose given in three words — "To fix color" — capped so that the use of nitrites, nitrates or a combination "shall not result in more than 200 ppm of nitrite, calculated as sodium nitrite in finished product". A barrel in a shed had no way of measuring that, which is why the modern home cure uses a measured curing salt instead of a scoop of saltpetre. For the cooking, the clearest old instruction is Fannie Merritt Farmer's, page 184 of The Boston Cooking-School Cook Book of 1896, under the heading Boiled Dinner, and it is four sentences long: warm unpressed corned beef served with cabbage, beets, turnips, carrots and potatoes; skim the fat off the meat water and cook the vegetables in it, "with exception of beets, which require a long time for cooking"; carrots take longer than cabbage or turnips; cabbage and beets are served in separate dishes. She is short about the meat itself — "Corned beef has but little nutritive value", she writes, and it "is eaten by the workingman to give bulk to his food" — which tells you what the dish was for.

Why this version works

The beets cook apart. This is the one rule in Farmer's four sentences that people break, and the pot goes uniformly pink when they do. Beets also want an hour where cabbage wants twelve minutes, so keeping them out solves two problems with one saucepan. They come back to the table in their own dish, and what is left of them becomes tomorrow's hash.

Below a boil, the whole way. Farmer puts the meat in cold water, brings it slowly to the boiling point, boils five minutes, skims, and then cooks it "at a lower temperature until tender". A hard boil squeezes a brisket into strings; the fibres tighten and push out the water the brine spent a month putting in. Hold the surface at a shiver, around 185°F, and three hours gets you meat you can cut with the side of a fork.

The vegetables go in backwards. Everything cooks in the beef broth, which is the point of the dish, but nothing survives three hours in it. Add by the clock rather than all at once: carrots and turnip first because they are dense, potatoes next, cabbage last and barely. Farmer says the same in her own order, and it is the difference between a boiled dinner and a pot of mush.

Salt is the risk, not the seasoning. A supermarket brisket has been in a pumped brine, not a barrel, and it carries more salt than a cure of the old kind ever left. Rinse it, start it in plenty of fresh cold water, throw away nothing but the scum, and taste the broth before the vegetables go in. If it is already too salty to drink, pour half of it off and top up with water — the vegetables are about to take up everything that is in there.

Ingredient notes

Beets: six medium, cooked in a separate pan of water with an inch of stem left on so they do not bleed out. Keep the cooked beets whatever you do not eat — half as much beet as potato turns the next day's hash into red flannel hash.

Turnip: New England means rutabaga when it says turnip in this dish — the big waxed yellow one, sold as swede in half the country. It wants an hour. Small white turnips can be used instead and go in with the potatoes, not before them.

Cabbage: a firm green head cut in wedges through the core, so the wedges hold together in the broth. Twelve to fifteen minutes is the whole of it. Cabbage cooked past that is where this dinner got its bad reputation.

The beef: a flat-cut brisket of about 4 pounds, which slices cleanly across the grain. Point cut has more fat and shreds instead of slicing. If a spice packet comes taped to it, use it or do not; the bay, peppercorn and allspice below is the same idea and you can see what it is.

Step by step

  1. Rinse and start cold. Rinse the brisket under cold water and put it fat side up in a heavy 8-quart pot. Cover with cold water by two inches, add the bay leaves, peppercorns and allspice, and bring slowly to a boil over medium heat.
  2. Skim, then drop the heat. Boil 5 minutes and skim off the grey foam. Lower the heat until the surface only shivers, around 185°F, cover part way, and cook 3 to 3½ hours, until a fork slides into the thickest part and comes out without lifting the meat.
  3. Beets in their own pan. While the beef cooks, put the beets in a saucepan of cold salted water, bring to a boil and simmer 40 to 50 minutes, until a knife goes through. Drain, cool enough to handle, slip off the skins and keep them warm.
    Beets cooking in a separate saucepan beside the corned beef pot
    Cook the beets separately to keep their colour out of the beef and vegetables. AI-generated illustration.
  4. Lift the beef and skim the broth. Move the beef to a platter and tent it with foil. Skim the fat off the broth and taste it — if it is fiercely salty, pour off a third and replace it with hot water.
  5. Vegetables by the clock. Bring the broth back to a simmer. Add the turnip and carrots and cook 15 minutes, then the potatoes and cook 15 minutes more, then the cabbage wedges and cook 12 to 15 minutes, until everything gives to a knife.
  6. Warm the beef through and serve. Slide the brisket back into the pot for the last 5 minutes to warm through. Slice it across the grain, pile the vegetables around it, and bring the beets and the butter to the table in their own dish with the parsley over them.
If the beef came out dry and stringy, the pot boiled while your back was turned — that is the only way it happens. It is not recoverable as slices, but it is entirely recoverable as dinner: chop it, moisten it with a ladle of the hot broth, and fold it into the potatoes as hash tonight instead of tomorrow. If the trouble is the opposite and the meat is still tough at three hours, it simply is not done; give it another forty minutes under a shivering surface and check again.

Storage and make-ahead

Keep the meat, the vegetables and a jar of the strained broth separately, 4 days refrigerated. Reheat the slices in a little broth in a covered pan over low heat; a microwave dries corned beef faster than anything else in the kitchen.

Red flannel hash is the point of the leftovers and it is in the 1896 book on page 189 as Corned Beef Hash with Beets: chop the cold beef, add an equal quantity of chopped boiled potato and half as much chopped cooked beet, season, moisten with milk or cream, and brown it slowly in a buttered pan without stirring before folding it onto a hot plate. The name red flannel hash is younger than the dish — it does not appear anywhere in the New Hampshire newspaper run searched here before 1936, while the boiled dinner itself is in those papers from 1851.

What to serve with it

Mustard on the plate and horseradish beside it, both sharp enough to cut the salt. Brown bread or a plain biscuit is the other half of the meal. If you want a drink with it, cider — sweet or hard — does more for corned beef than beer does.

A platter of sliced corned beef surrounded by potatoes, carrots, turnip chunks and cabbage wedges, with a separate bowl of dark red beets beside it

From the recipe box / New Hampshire

New England Boiled Dinner

Corned beef simmered until it gives, then the root vegetables cooked in its broth in the order they take to soften, and the beets kept out of the pot so the dinner stays its own colour.

Prep
30 min
Cook
4 hr
Total
4 hr 30 min
Serves
8
Calories
560 per serving

Ingredients

Scale

Instructions

  1. Rinse the brisket, put it in an 8-quart pot with cold water to cover by 2 inches, add the bay, peppercorns and allspice, and bring slowly to a boil.
  2. Boil 5 minutes, skim, then hold at a bare shiver around 185°F and cook 3–3½ hours, until a fork slides in easily.
  3. Meanwhile simmer the beets in a separate pan of salted water 40–50 minutes, drain, slip off the skins and keep warm.
  4. Lift the beef to a platter and tent it. Skim the broth and taste it, diluting with hot water if it is very salty.
  5. Simmer the rutabaga and carrots 15 minutes, add the potatoes for 15 minutes, then the cabbage wedges for 12–15 minutes.
  6. Return the beef to the pot for 5 minutes to warm, then slice across the grain and serve with the vegetables, the buttered beets in their own dish, parsley, mustard and horseradish.

Nutrition

Fat28 g (10 g saturated)
Sodium1290 mg
Protein33 g
ServingAbout 5 oz beef with vegetables
Calories560
Cholesterol95 mg
Carbohydrates42 g (14 g sugar, 8 g fiber)

Nutrition is an estimate calculated from the listed ingredients and is provided as a courtesy, not as dietary advice.

Questions readers ask

Can I corn my own beef?

Yes, and the USDA formula above is the shape of it, but do not use saltpetre by eye. Buy a commercial curing salt, follow the weight on its packet for your weight of meat, and you land inside the 200 ppm ceiling that 9 CFR 424.21 sets for nitrite in a finished cured product. A 4-pound brisket in a brine of a gallon of water, a cup of kosher salt, half a cup of sugar and the packet dose of curing salt needs about seven days in the refrigerator, turned daily — a barrel cure of a month is scaled for a whole beef in a cold shed, not for a fridge.

Can this be done in a slow cooker?

The meat can. Six to eight hours on low with water to cover gives you the same tender brisket, and the low setting never boils, which removes the one way this dish goes wrong. The vegetables still want the stovetop at the end, in the order given, because a slow cooker cannot tell a carrot from a cabbage wedge.

Why does my corned beef come out grey?

Because it was cured without nitrate or nitrite. That is not a fault; it is what plain salt does, and the meat tastes the same. The pink is a fixed colour, and the federal table says so in the plainest possible words: the listed purpose of sodium nitrite in cured meat is to fix colour.

Should I use the spice packet that comes with the brisket?

It is pickling spice — mustard seed, coriander, bay, allspice, sometimes dill seed and chilli. Use it if you like it. The bay, peppercorns and allspice here do the same job in a quieter way, and either is better than nothing, since the broth becomes the cooking liquid for every vegetable on the plate.