Skillet & Sage

The regional table / Hawaii

Loco Moco

Most of the dishes on this site have an origin story nobody can test. This one has a sociologist who went to Hilo and asked, and published the answer in 1983.

The University of Hawaii keeps its own journal, Social Process in Hawaii, in an open repository, and volume 30 of 1983 carries an article by James Kelly called "Loco Moco: A Folk Dish in the Making" at pages 59 to 64. It is the document this dish deserves and almost no young dish gets. Kelly places the invention at a small cafe called the Lincoln Grill in downtown Hilo, on the island of Hawaii, and credits it to the restaurant's owners and operators, Mr and Mrs Richard Inouye, in 1949. His account of why is specific: it began as an attempt to feed a group of teenage boys who had tired of American sandwiches but would not wait for the slower cooking of the Japanese and Chinese dishes on offer. The contents, he reports, were suggested by Mrs Nancy Inouye — rice was already a staple of the cafe and so was the gravy that went over it, Mr Inouye having previously worked at the Royal Hawaiian Hotel in Honolulu where he learned to make sauces and gravies, and the hamburger patty was already on the menu because the cafe served everything. Two of Kelly's details change how you cook it. The egg, he says, was added some years after the original invention, so the founding dish was rice, patty and gravy alone. And the name came from the boys: they tried to assemble one out of their own initials, failed, and fell back on the nickname of the boy who ate the first one, which was "crazy" — loco in Portuguese and in Hawaii pidgin — with moco attached for no reason beyond the rhyme. Kelly also notes, which is the part that matters for anyone retelling this, that most people he asked assumed the dish had been invented on the plantations. The folk version of the story was already wrong in 1983.

What the newspaper archives add is not the origin but the spread, and it is a good measure of it. The Florida Digital Newspaper Library holds a run of Pacific service papers, and the dish turns up in them as ordinary institutional food: the Kwajalein Hourglass of 14 July 2007 lists loco moco on an Army dining-hall menu between beef and broccoli and pasta spirals, and the Hawaii Marine of 8 January 2010 has the cooks turning out loco moco plates alongside omelets, French toast and pancakes. A Florida diner was advertising it on 11 October 2006, in the same breath as eggs Benedict and bottomless mimosas. Georgia's historic newspapers have two pages and both are after 2010. So in under sixty years the thing went from one Hilo lunch counter to the chow line of an atoll two thousand miles away. One trap for anyone searching: in that same Florida collection the phrase returns a handful of nineteenth-century hits from the Diario de Pernambuco, and every one of them is the Portuguese word locomotiva broken across a line end — loco at the right margin, moco at the left. Nobody cooks for this site and there is no public-domain recipe for a dish invented in 1949; the gravy below is scaled from a federal recipe card and everything else follows Kelly's description of what was actually in the bowl.

Why this version works

Four components, one of them unsalted, and the bowl matters. Rice as cooked without salt carries zero sodium; the patty about 83 milligrams per hundred; the gravy and the egg bring the rest. That division is why the dish tastes balanced at a serving size that looks enormous — there is a large unsalted cushion under everything, which is also why under-seasoning the gravy ruins it and over-seasoning it is almost impossible. Build it in a bowl rather than on a plate, which Kelly's 1983 description makes a point of, often a waxed paper one: the gravy has to pool and be eaten with a spoon, and on a flat plate it runs to the rim and the rice at the edges stays dry.

The egg is a later addition and its job is to be a second sauce. Kelly is explicit that the egg arrived some years after 1949, which tells you it was not structural to the original and is therefore free to do something else — and what it does is supply a second, richer sauce from the yolk. A fried egg runs 14.8 grams of fat and 401 milligrams of cholesterol per hundred grams against the gravy's almost nothing, so breaking the yolk into the gravy changes its body as well as its flavour. Fry it over easy, as the 1983 description specifies: white fully set, yolk liquid, no colour on top. A hard yolk turns the richest thing in the bowl into a dry crumb sitting on a wet dish.

The rice has to clump, and the federal grain classes tell you what to buy. Cooked white rice is 68.6 percent water by USDA's measurement, so the scoop at the bottom of the bowl is already wet before a ladle of gravy lands on it. What keeps it a scoop rather than a puddle is grain type. The standards at 7 CFR 868.302 set out seven classes of milled rice, four of them — Long Grain, Medium Grain, Short Grain and Mixed — defined by whole-kernel percentage and type, and you want medium or short, which hold together when cooked and let a spoon lift rice, patty and gravy in one go. Long grain stays separate and the dish comes apart. Read the bag knowing the tolerance: a lot graded U.S. No. 1 medium grain may legally carry up to 10 percent of whole or broken long grain kernels.

The gravy is the dish, and the Armed Forces Recipe Service says how far to take the roux. Card No. O 016 00, Brown Gravy, yields a hundred quarter-cup portions from roughly equal weights of flour and fat — one and three-eighths pounds of flour to one and an eighth of shortening — loosened with a gallon and a half of beef broth. Its instruction on colour is the useful part: sprinkle the flour over the drippings, then cook it "at low heat on top of range ... or in 375 F. oven for 30 minutes until flour is a rich brown color", stirring frequently, before the stock goes in and the whole thing simmers ten minutes. Thirty minutes is longer than most home cooks give a roux and it is why canteen gravy tastes of something. Note also the portion: a quarter of a cup. A loco moco wants twice that, which means a thicker roux than the card implies if the rice underneath is not to turn to porridge.

Ingredient notes

The beef: a pound of coarse-ground chuck at about 80 percent lean, in four patties, each pressed a little wider than it needs to be and dimpled in the centre so it stays flat. Season the outsides only, and season them properly — this is a hamburger steak rather than a burger, so there is no bun to carry salt and no condiment coming. Four ounces is the right weight against a cup of rice; a six-ounce patty crowds the bowl and unbalances the gravy.

The eggs: one large egg per bowl, fried over easy in a separate pan with a little butter or oil, on a gentler heat than the patties. The white should be opaque and set to the edge with no transparent patch near the yolk, and the yolk should still move when you tip the pan. Cook them last, while the gravy is going over the rice, and get them onto the bowls within a minute. Scatter sliced spring onion over the top if you like; it is not in the 1983 account but it is on most Hawaii menus now and it is the only thing in the bowl with any sharpness.

The rice: four cups cooked, from about one and a half cups of raw medium-grain or short-grain white rice. Cook it a touch firmer than you would to eat alone, because it is going to take on gravy and sit for a minute before it is eaten. Do not salt the cooking water; the dish needs that unsalted cushion. Day-old refrigerated rice reheated in a steamer works well and is what a busy counter uses. Long grain and basmati are the wrong objects here, and brown rice, while perfectly edible, has a chew that fights the softness the dish is built on.

The gravy: a third of a cup each of butter and plain flour, and three cups of beef broth, which scales the federal card up to about half a cup of finished gravy per person. Use a broth you would drink; the gravy is three-quarters stock and there is nowhere for a poor one to hide. If you have pan drippings from the patties, and you will, the card is explicit that they go into the roux — "Scrape and use brown particles remaining in pan" — so make the gravy in the pan the meat came out of. A splash of soy sauce at the end is common in Hawaii and entirely in keeping with how the dish was assembled in the first place.

Step by step

  1. Cook the rice and keep it hot. Cook a cup and a half of medium-grain white rice without salt by whatever method you trust, aiming slightly firm, and keep it covered and hot. Four warmed bowls — deep ones, not plates — ready beside the stove.
  2. Shape and griddle the patties. Divide the beef into four, pat each into a round about half an inch thick with a dimple in the middle, and salt and pepper both faces. Fry in a heavy pan over medium-high heat in a little oil, 3 minutes on the first side and 2 to 3 on the second, without pressing them. Lift them onto a plate and leave the pan and everything in it exactly as it is.
  3. Build the roux in the meat pan and brown it properly. Drop the butter into the hot pan with the drippings and brown particles, let it melt, then sprinkle the flour over evenly and stir. Now cook it, on a low heat, for a good 15 to 20 minutes, stirring often, until it has gone the colour of a hazelnut shell and smells toasted. The federal card gives this stage half an hour at 375 degrees; in a pan over direct heat it is faster but it is still the longest step in the recipe and the one that decides whether the gravy tastes of anything.
  4. Add the broth and simmer it to coating thickness. Pour in the three cups of broth in three or four additions, stirring hard after each so the roux takes up the liquid without lumping. Bring it to the boil, drop it to a simmer and cook 10 minutes until it coats a spoon and holds a line drawn through it with a finger. Season with black pepper, taste, and add salt or a splash of soy sauce as needed. Keep it hot.
  5. Fry the eggs over easy. In a separate pan over medium-low heat with a little butter, fry the four eggs until the whites are set to the edges and the yolks are still loose, 2 to 3 minutes, basting the whites with the fat rather than flipping them. Do not cover the pan, which steams the yolk and sets a skin over it.
  6. Assemble in order and serve immediately. A cup of rice into each bowl and flatten the top slightly. A patty on the rice. Then a generous half-cup of gravy ladled over everything, patty and rice both, so nothing is dry. The egg goes on last, on top of the gravy, and the spring onion over that. Serve at once with a spoon, and break the yolk at the table.
Thin gravy is the usual complaint and it has two causes: not enough roux for the volume of stock, or not enough simmering. Simmer it longer before you reach for anything else, and if it is still loose, work a teaspoon of flour into a knob of soft butter and whisk that in a little at a time. Lumpy gravy means the broth went in too fast and cold; push it through a sieve and carry on, nobody will know. A pale, floury-tasting gravy was not browned long enough, and there is no fixing it after the stock is in, so give the roux its full fifteen minutes next time. If the rice at the bottom has gone to paste, the gravy was too thin or the bowl sat too long before it was eaten; this is a dish to carry straight to the table. And a hard yolk cannot be undone, so fry the eggs last and plate them within the minute.

Storage and make-ahead

The parts keep separately and the assembled bowl does not keep at all — give it five minutes before the rice begins to turn. Gravy is the one component that improves: it keeps 4 days refrigerated and 3 months frozen, thickens as it cools and comes back with a splash of broth over a low heat. Cooked patties keep 3 days and are better reheated in the gravy than in a pan. Cooked rice keeps 4 days refrigerated, and is safest cooled quickly and reheated hot all the way through.

Which makes this a good dish to engineer rather than cook from scratch at the last minute: gravy on Sunday, patties cooked and refrigerated, rice in the cooker, and then four minutes of assembly and four fried eggs on a weeknight. That is more or less how a lunch counter does it, which is where the dish comes from and what it was designed around — a plate that can be put together in front of a customer out of three things already hot.

What to serve with it

Nothing, traditionally, and that is the honest answer: a loco moco is a complete plate lunch on its own and arrives in a bowl that leaves no room for a side. If you want to build it out, the Hawaii plate-lunch convention is a scoop of macaroni salad beside it and nothing else, which sounds odd next to gravy and works because it is cold and sour. A few slices of cucumber in vinegar does the same job with less weight.

To drink, something cold and plain — iced tea, cold milk, a lemon-lime soda, or Hawaii's own habit of a canned iced coffee. Anything sweet and heavy competes with the gravy. Afterwards, fresh pineapple or a slice of melon, because the one thing the bowl has no trace of is acid or fruit.

From the recipe box / Hawaii

Loco Moco

A scoop of medium-grain rice under a hamburger steak, brown gravy poured over everything and an over-easy egg on top — a dish whose origin is unusually well documented, down to the Hilo cafe, the year, the couple who made it and the schoolboy whose nickname it carries.

Prep
15 min
Cook
30 min
Total
45 min
Serves
4
Calories
710 per serving

Ingredients

Scale

Instructions

  1. Cook the rice without salt, slightly firm, and keep it hot with four deep bowls warming.
  2. Shape four half-inch patties, season the outsides, and fry in oil over medium-high heat 3 minutes then 2 to 3 more; lift out and keep the pan as it is.
  3. Melt the butter into the drippings, sprinkle over the flour, and cook on low 15 to 20 minutes, stirring often, until the roux is hazelnut brown.
  4. Add the broth in three or four additions, stirring hard, then boil and simmer 10 minutes to coating thickness; season with pepper and soy sauce.
  5. Fry the eggs over easy in a separate pan, basting rather than flipping, until the whites are set and the yolks loose.
  6. Put a cup of rice in each bowl, a patty on the rice, a generous half-cup of gravy over everything, then the egg and the spring onion; serve at once.

Nutrition

Fat36 g (17 g saturated)
Sodium640 mg
Protein32 g
Servingone bowl, with gravy and egg
Calories710
Cholesterol305 mg
Carbohydrates62 g (1 g sugar, 1 g fiber)

Nutrition is an estimate calculated from the listed ingredients and is provided as a courtesy, not as dietary advice.

Questions readers ask

Does it have to have the egg?

Historically, no — and that is the most useful thing in Kelly's article for a cook. He states that the egg was added some years after the dish was invented, which means rice, hamburger steak and gravy is the original article and a perfectly legitimate thing to serve. Nobody in Hawaii would recognise a loco moco without an egg today, so by all means put it on; but knowing it is a later addition tells you how to treat it. It is not holding the dish together, so it can be as loose and rich as you like, and over easy with the yolk broken at the table is the version the 1983 description gives.

Where does the name come from?

From a boy's nickname, according to the same source. Kelly reports that the teenagers who ate the first ones wanted a name built from their own initials, could not make one work, and used instead the nickname of the one who ate the first loco moco. The nickname was "crazy", which is loco in Portuguese and in Hawaii pidgin — Portuguese being one of the plantation languages that fed into that pidgin. Moco means nothing at all; Kelly says it was picked because it rhymed and sounded better than the alternatives they tried. That is an unusually complete etymology for a dish of this age, and it is the kind that gets replaced by a tidier invention if nobody writes it down.

Who actually invented it, and when?

The best answer available is James Kelly's, published in Social Process in Hawaii in 1983 and freely readable in the University of Hawaii's repository: the Lincoln Grill in downtown Hilo, in 1949, by the cafe's owners Mr and Mrs Richard Inouye, with the contents suggested by Mrs Nancy Inouye. Kelly explains the circumstances too — a snack improvised for teenage boys who wanted something faster than the cafe's Japanese and Chinese dishes and less dull than a sandwich. It is worth saying what that makes this: not an untestable founding legend but a dated account gathered a generation later by somebody who went and asked. Kelly also records that most people he spoke to believed the dish came off the plantations, so the wrong story was already circulating in 1983 and has had forty years more to settle.

Can I use a different gravy, or a packet?

You can, and plenty of places do, but the gravy is where the dish was actually made — Kelly notes that Mr Inouye had learned sauces and gravies working at the Royal Hawaiian Hotel before he had a cafe of his own, and that both the rice and the gravy were already standing items on the Lincoln Grill's menu when the boys walked in. A roux browned for a full fifteen or twenty minutes in the pan the patties came out of is not much more work than a packet and is a completely different thing to eat. If you do use a packet, make it up with beef broth rather than water, and stir it into the meat drippings rather than into a clean pan.