American cooking Recipes & regional stories

Skillet & Sage

A culinary journey through the fifty states

The regional table / Rhode Island

Rhode Island Doughboys

Published September 23, 2026 · Rhode Island

Jump to Recipe

A clam cake has clams in it. A doughboy has nothing in it, and that is the entire difference between them.

The word is older than the food and it belonged to the services. Admiral W. H. Smyth, The Sailor's Word-Book, London 1867, has the entry between DOUBLOON and DOUSE: dough-boys are hard dumplings boiled in salt water, and he calls the word a corruption of dough-balls. Twenty years later Elizabeth B. Custer printed her husband's letter of 28 March 1867 from Abilene Creek — he had ridden past the infantry that morning and wrote "Wasn't I glad I was not a doughboy" — and hung a footnote on it in Tenting on the Plains, 1887: "A 'doughboy' is a small, round doughnut served to sailors on shipboard, generally with hash. Early in the Civil War the term was applied to the large globular brass buttons of the infantry uniform, from which it passed, by a natural transition, to the infantrymen themselves." Boiled dumpling, then fried round, then the button it looked like, then the man wearing it. What the word did not mean was a New England snack. John Russell Bartlett's Dictionary of Americanisms, fourth edition, Boston 1884 — copyright entered, the title page says, in the Clerk's Office of the District Court for the District of Rhode Island — runs Dough, Dough-Faces, Dough-Facism, Dough-Head and then straight into Doughnut, with no dough-boy anywhere in the alphabet. The War Department's own Manual for Army Cooks of 1917 defines dumplings at paragraph 69 as pieces of dough, boiled or baked, and never uses the word doughboy once, in the year the word was being printed a thousand times a week about the men in France.

The Rhode Island food is late, and the newspapers say so plainly. The Pawtucket papers on the Advantage Preservation network run from 1825 to 1976 and return just over nine hundred pages for the exact word "doughboys". The earliest is 13 March 1899, a Spanish-American War memoir out of Tampa; then twenty-nine pages in 1918, seventy-six in 1919, a hundred and eighty-four in 1944. Every one of them is a soldier. The food appears only at the end of the run, and quietly: a Pawtucket Times column of 30 December 1955 remembering a mother at the black stove "beating up some batter for hot doughboys"; an advertisement in the Cranston Herald of 21 May 1970 in which the Modern A&W at 115 Budlong Road announces, in letter-spaced capitals under the giant hamburger, "ALSO OUR NEW DOUGHBOYS & CLAMCAKES"; a classified in the Pawtucket Times of 31 May 1975 for a flea market at the Good Shepherd church on Broadway with a pastry table "including Portugese Doughboys (Filhos)". The fullest account is the Cranston Herald of 17 August 1977, page six, on the St Rocco's feast in Johnston, and it is a recipe in all but name. What no document I could reach gives is a quantity, so the ones below are this site's own, worked out for this page. Two holes in the record are worth naming: the Providence Journal is not in this network at all, and the Cranston run is missing 1904 to 1920 entirely.

Why this version works

Four things go in the dough. The 1977 Cranston Herald piece follows the feast kitchen from the bin outward: they mix a hundred pounds of dough at a time, and in a large bin three people mix flour, yeast, salt and water. That is the whole list. No egg, no milk, no butter, no sugar in the dough, which is what separates this from every doughnut in the American canon and why a doughboy tastes of fried bread rather than of cake.

Hand-stretched, never rolled. The same account: "The dough is then hand stretched by pulling it in all directions to form a circle eight inches in diameter." A rolling pin presses the gas out of a risen dough and gives you an even, dense disc. Pulling it leaves the big holes where they are and gives a round that is thin and translucent at the centre and thick at the rim, so one doughboy has two textures in it.

A slow rise, then ninety seconds. Mrs. D. A. Lincoln, in the Boston Cook Book of 1884, builds Raised Doughnuts on "1 pint risen milk bread dough" and adds one flat line: "These are more wholesome than those made with soda." Fannie Farmer's raised doughnuts, in the 1910 printing of the Boston Cooking-School Cook Book whose copyright runs from 1896 to 1906, rise overnight, are shaped, rise again on the floured board, and go into deep fat. The lineage is not a doughnut with the sugar changed; it is fermented bread dough that happens to be fried.

The sugar goes on hot, and nobody wrote down why. Farmer ends her raised doughnuts with "Cool, and roll in powdered sugar," which is the opposite of the practice at every Rhode Island stand: granulated sugar, thrown on while the thing is still too hot to hold, so the film of oil catches the crystals instead of shedding them. I could not date that change. The 1977 feast account follows the dough from the mixing bin to the fryer to the server and never mentions sugar at all.

Ingredient notes

Flour: bread flour, four cups. The dough has to survive being pulled to the width of a dinner plate without tearing in the middle, and all-purpose will do it only if you treat it gently. Whatever you use, weigh it if you can — four cups scooped hard out of the bag can be sixty grams heavier than four cups spooned in, and that is the difference between a stretchy round and a leathery one.

Frying fat: a quart of peanut, corn or any neutral oil, two inches deep in a heavy pot. Depth matters more than volume — a doughboy has to float and turn freely, and a shallow pan gives you a pale ring where the dough sat on the bottom. Keep a thermometer in the pot; this is a dough that goes from raw to burnt inside twenty seconds.

Salt and sugar: a teaspoon and a half of fine salt in the dough, because there is nothing else in there to taste. The cup of sugar is not an ingredient so much as a place to land: put it in a wide bowl or a paper bag before you start frying, not after, because these want tossing the second they leave the fat.

Water and yeast: a third over a cup and a quarter of warm water to five hundred grams of flour, which is a soft dough that stays slack enough to pull. Instant yeast goes in dry with the flour. A packet is more than this needs; half of one and a longer rise gives more flavour, and the fridge overnight gives more still.

Step by step

  1. Mix the four things. Whisk the flour, yeast and salt together in a large bowl. Pour in the warm water and stir with a wooden spoon until no dry flour is left, then knead in the bowl or on the counter for 6 to 8 minutes, until the dough is smooth and springs back slowly when pressed. It should feel tacky but not sticky.
  2. Let it rise. Cover the bowl and leave it at room temperature for 1½ to 2 hours, until doubled and domed. For a better flavour, refrigerate it overnight instead and take it out an hour before frying; the dough will be easier to pull cold-risen than warm.
  3. Divide and rest. Turn the dough out without punching it down — the gas in it is the open crumb you want — and cut it into 12 pieces of about 70 grams. Round each one loosely, set them on a floured tray under a cloth, and leave them 20 to 30 minutes. This rest is what lets them stretch instead of snapping back.
  4. Heat the fat and set up the sugar. Bring 2 inches of oil to 365°F in a heavy pot. Put the sugar in a wide bowl or a paper bag, set a cooling rack beside the stove, and keep the tray of dough within reach. Once you start frying there is no time to fetch anything.
  5. Stretch and fry. Take one piece, flatten it with your fingers, then pull it in every direction over your knuckles until it is a rough circle 6 to 7 inches across and thin enough at the centre to see light through. Lay it into the oil away from you. It will puff and float in seconds; fry 60 to 90 seconds, turn with tongs, and give it 45 to 60 seconds on the second side, until both faces are gold and blistered. Fry two at a time, no more, and let the oil come back to temperature between batches.
  6. Sugar them at once. Lift each one out, hold it over the pot for three seconds to drip, then drop it straight into the sugar and toss until it is coated on both sides. Move it to the rack. Do not stack them; they steam each other soft. Eat them standing up, before the next two come out.
Heavy and greasy means the fat was too cool, and Mrs. Lincoln printed the test for it in 1884: a piece dropped in "should rise at once to the surface, with much spluttering of the fat, swell, and begin to brown on the under side." If yours sinks and sits there, stop, bring the oil back to 365°F, and fry fewer at a time. The other failure is a doughboy that will not stretch and tears into a rag: the dough was underrested, so cover the rest of the pieces and wait another fifteen minutes before trying again. A round that came out thick and bready through the middle was not pulled thin enough, and no amount of extra frying fixes it — it only browns the outside further.

Storage and make-ahead

They do not keep, and nobody at a stand pretends otherwise. A doughboy is good for about ten minutes, acceptable for an hour and leathery by evening; sugared and left overnight it weeps and turns sticky. Fry what will be eaten standing in the kitchen and no more.

The dough is the part that keeps. It holds three days covered in the fridge and improves over the first two, and it freezes in portioned balls for a month — thaw them in the fridge overnight, then rest them an hour at room temperature before pulling. Cold dough that has not warmed up will fight you and tear.

What to serve with it

At the shore stands these come out of the same fat as the chowder's clam cakes and land on the same tray, which is the whole argument for frying them last, after something savoury has gone through the oil. Coffee milk if you are being local about it, strong black coffee if you are not, and nothing sweet to drink alongside — the sugar on the outside is already doing that job.

From the recipe box / Rhode Island

Rhode Island Doughboys

A flat round of risen dough pulled thin between the hands, dropped into deep fat and thrown hot into sugar. Four things in the dough and nothing at all in the middle.

Prep
2 hr 25 min
Cook
20 min
Total
2 hr 45 min
Serves
6
Calories
510 per serving

Ingredients

Scale

Instructions

  1. Whisk the flour, yeast and salt in a large bowl, stir in the warm water, and knead 6 to 8 minutes until smooth and tacky.
  2. Cover and rise 1½ to 2 hours at room temperature until doubled, or refrigerate overnight and warm an hour before frying.
  3. Turn the dough out without deflating it, cut into 12 pieces of about 70 g, round loosely, and rest on a floured tray 20 to 30 minutes.
  4. Heat 2 inches of oil to 365°F, put the sugar in a wide bowl or paper bag, and set a rack beside the stove.
  5. Pull each piece over your knuckles to a 6- to 7-inch circle thin enough to see light through, and fry two at a time, 60 to 90 seconds a side, until gold and blistered.
  6. Drip each one over the pot, toss it straight into the sugar while it is too hot to hold, and move it to the rack in a single layer.

Nutrition

Fat15 g (2 g saturated)
Sodium600 mg
Protein10 g
Serving2 doughboys
Calories510
Cholesterol0 mg
Carbohydrates83 g (20 g sugar, 3 g fiber)

Nutrition is an estimate calculated from the listed ingredients and is provided as a courtesy, not as dietary advice.

Questions readers ask

Granulated or powdered sugar?

Granulated, thrown on while they are still hot enough to hurt. Farmer's raised doughnuts say to cool them first and roll them in powdered sugar, which gives a dry, dusty coat that falls off in the bag. Hot and granulated, the sugar sticks in the film of oil and keeps a little crunch. Cinnamon is a modern addition and nobody will stop you, but the plain version is the one being sold.

Can I make the dough the day before?

That is the better way to do it. Mix it, let it start at room temperature for an hour, then refrigerate overnight; the slow ferment gives a flavour you cannot get in two hours, and cold dough stretches more willingly than warm. Take it out an hour ahead, divide, rest, and fry as usual.

Can I use pizza or bread dough from the shop?

Yes, and it is the honest shortcut, because the feast kitchen the Cranston Herald described in 1977 was mixing flour, yeast, salt and water — the same four things. Let a pound of bought dough come fully to room temperature, cut it into six pieces, rest them half an hour and pull them as above. Sweet or enriched doughs are the wrong thing: anything with egg, milk or sugar in it browns long before the middle cooks.

Is a doughboy just a clam cake without the clams?

No, and the two are not even the same kind of mixture. A clam cake is a wet batter dropped from a spoon; a doughboy is a fermented dough that is risen, cut, rested and pulled by hand. They share a pot of fat at the same stands and nothing else. The Cranston Herald advertisement of 21 May 1970 that first puts the food word in print in these papers names both in the same line, which is exactly how they are sold.