American cooking Recipes & regional stories

Skillet & Sage

A culinary journey through the fifty states

The regional table / Mississippi

Fried Catfish with Comeback Sauce

Published September 22, 2026 · Mississippi

Four golden cornmeal-crusted catfish fillets on a wire rack above a tray beside pale orange comeback sauce and saltine crackers
The crust should look sandy and matte, not glossy. Fine cornmeal fries dry; the gloss on the plate comes from the sauce. AI-generated illustration.
Jump to Recipe

The fish is tasted for flavor before it is ever caught, and the sauce is made the day before. What happens between those two facts takes about fifteen minutes.

Almost every catfish fillet sold in this country comes out of a pond, and most of those ponds are in Mississippi. The Mississippi Encyclopedia entry on catfish farming, written by Terry Hanson of Mississippi State University, dates commercial production in the state to about 1965 and puts 85 percent of the acreage in the Delta, where the alluvial aquifer sits close enough under the clay to fill a levee pond and the clay is tight enough to hold it. The scale is still there in the federal numbers: USDA's National Agricultural Statistics Service, in the Catfish Production report released on 15 July 2026, counted 27,900 of the 41,100 water surface acres in the three major producing states in Mississippi alone. What makes that worth knowing at the stove is a detail from the Mississippi State Extension Service, the land-grant service for the state that grows the fish. Before a pond is harvested, a sample goes to the processor and is cooked and tasted by people employed to taste it — two weeks out, the day before, and the day of. Fish that come back positive for the earthy compounds geosmin and 2-methylisoborneol, which pond algae make and which are harmless but unmistakable, are refused and the pond goes back on the schedule until it clears. The fish are taken off feed two or three days before harvest. From live tank to ice, Extension puts the whole processing run at under thirty minutes.

The sauce is a Jackson story and a Greek one. Malcolm White's entry on comeback sauce in the Mississippi Encyclopedia opens by saying there are nearly as many spellings of the name as there are recipes and theories of origin, and it is careful about what can be shown: paper records for a family salad dressing are scarce, and the oral histories point to Five Points. Most accounts land on Alex Dennery, born John Alexander Tounaris in Greece, and his Rotisserie on US 49, a converted drive-in at a junction of five streets with a door on each; the date usually given is 1936, and the encyclopedia says "supposedly" when it gives it. Mike Kountouris of the Mayflower Café is quoted there on why Greek immigrants were behind the counter in the first place — with no English, kitchen and busboy work was the work available. This was never a large community: Ted Ownby's entry on Greeks in Mississippi counts 117 people of Greek birth in the state in the 1910 census, 207 in 1920, 342 in 1930. A few hundred people gave the state its house dressing. No old book holds the measurements, so the ones below were worked out for this page against what the record does agree on — mayonnaise, chili sauce, a great deal of garlic, and enough of it that the bottle goes back to the kitchen empty.

Why this version works

Cornmeal alone, no batter. A wet batter puffs, traps steam against the fish and slumps within a minute of leaving the oil. Dry fine cornmeal held on by buttermilk fries into a thin sandy shell that stays crisp long enough to get to the table, which is the only test that matters when you are cooking four fillets in two batches.

The oil at 350°F, and back to 350°F. Fillets an inch thick at the shoulder need six or seven minutes, and at 350°F the crust colors at about the rate the center cooks. Four fillets dropped at once will take the fat down to 300°F and hold it there, and cornmeal that sits in cool oil drinks it. Fry two at a time and let the pot recover between batches.

The sauce is made first and left alone. Grated raw garlic and grated onion are harsh for the first hour in mayonnaise and round out by the next day. An overnight rest is the difference between a sharp orange mayonnaise and the thing people eat off crackers while they wait for the salad.

Buttermilk with hot sauce, twenty minutes. Long enough to leave the surface tacky so the meal grips, short enough that the acid does not start firming the flesh. Catfish is mild and slightly sweet, and the vinegar in the hot sauce gives the crust something to answer to.

Ingredient notes

Catfish: Four farm-raised fillets of about 6 ounces. Extension's product list is worth reading at the counter: whole dressed fish, shank fillets with the belly removed, and nuggets, which are the belly flaps cut off the fillet by hand. Nuggets fry beautifully and cost less; they just need a minute less in the oil. Frozen fillets are fine — thaw them overnight in the fridge and dry them hard.

Cornmeal: Fine plain yellow cornmeal, not stone-ground coarse and not a self-rising mix, which carries leavening and salt you cannot then control. A half cup of flour in with it softens the grit slightly and helps the crust hold together. If all you have is coarse meal, sift it and use what falls through.

Frying fat: Peanut oil for its smoke point and clean taste, or lard if you have it. Two inches in a heavy pot is enough to float a fillet; a Dutch oven holds temperature far better than a thin skillet. A clip-on thermometer is not optional here.

For the sauce: Full-fat jarred mayonnaise, bottled chili sauce, Worcestershire, yellow mustard and more garlic than looks reasonable. Grate the garlic and the onion on a rasp rather than chopping them, so they dissolve into the sauce instead of sitting in it as bits.

Step by step

  1. Make the sauce a day ahead. Whisk the mayonnaise, chili sauce, ketchup, Worcestershire, mustard, lemon juice, grated garlic, grated onion, paprika, black pepper and 2 tablespoons water in a bowl until smooth and pourable. Cover and refrigerate at least 4 hours, ideally overnight. It makes about 1½ cups.
  2. Soak the fish. Pat the fillets dry, lay them in a dish, pour over the buttermilk whisked with the hot sauce, and turn them once. Leave 20 minutes at room temperature while the oil heats.
  3. Season the meal. Stir the cornmeal, flour, salt, black pepper, cayenne and garlic powder together in a wide shallow dish. Taste a pinch — it should be a little saltier than you think right.
  4. Heat the oil. Pour 2 inches of peanut oil into a Dutch oven and bring it to 350°F. Set a rack over a baking sheet next to the stove; paper towels laid flat will steam the underside of the crust, so drain on the rack.
  5. Dredge and fry in two batches. Lift a fillet out, let the buttermilk run off for a second, and press it into the meal on both sides and along the edges. Slide two fillets into the oil away from you and fry 6 to 7 minutes, turning once, until the crust is deep gold and the fish flakes at the thick end. Keep the fat between 335 and 350°F. Recover the heat before the second batch.
  6. Drain standing up. Stand each fillet on the rack on its edge, propped against the next one, so the oil runs off both faces instead of pooling underneath. Salt them the moment they come out of the pot and serve within a few minutes, with the sauce in a bowl and crackers beside it.
    Cornmeal-crusted catfish fillets propped on edge on a wire rack
    Stand the fillets on edge on a rack so oil drains from both faces. AI-generated illustration.
A soft crust means one of two things and both are heat. Either the oil never came back to 350°F between batches, or the pot was crowded and four fillets took it down at once. There is no fixing the batch you have, but a fillet that has gone soft will come most of the way back on a rack in a 425°F oven for 5 minutes. If the sauce tastes raw and sharp, it has not had its rest yet: leave it another night rather than trying to balance it with sugar, which only makes it taste like bottled dressing.

Storage and make-ahead

Fried fillets keep 2 days refrigerated. Reheat on a rack in a 425°F oven for 6 to 8 minutes; the microwave turns the cornmeal to paste.

The sauce keeps 2 weeks in a sealed jar in the fridge and is better on day two than day one. Make double — it goes on fried chicken, boiled shrimp, cold roast pork, french fries, and, as the Mississippi Encyclopedia notes without embarrassment, straight onto saltines.

What to serve with it

Coleslaw, hushpuppies and dill pickles are the plate this comes on in Mississippi, and the slaw does the real work — something vinegary and cold against a plate of fried food. Sweet tea or cold beer, and a bowl of comeback within reach of everyone at the table rather than one bottle passed around.

Four golden cornmeal-crusted catfish fillets on a wire rack above a tray beside pale orange comeback sauce and saltine crackers

From the recipe box / Mississippi

Fried Catfish with Comeback Sauce

Pond-raised fillets in a fine cornmeal crust, fried hot and drained standing up, with the orange garlic dressing that Jackson's Greek restaurant families put on everything.

Prep
20 min
Cook
20 min
Total
45 min plus rest
Serves
4
Calories
812 per serving

Ingredients

Scale

Instructions

  1. Whisk the mayonnaise, chili sauce, ketchup, Worcestershire, mustard, lemon juice, garlic, onion, paprika, ½ teaspoon of the black pepper and 2 tablespoons water. Refrigerate 4 hours or overnight.
  2. Soak the dried fillets in the buttermilk whisked with the hot sauce for 20 minutes.
  3. Stir the cornmeal, flour, 2 teaspoons salt, the remaining black pepper, the cayenne and the garlic powder together in a shallow dish.
  4. Heat 2 inches of peanut oil in a Dutch oven to 350°F and set a rack over a baking sheet alongside.
  5. Press each drained fillet into the meal on both sides and fry two at a time, turning once, 6–7 minutes at 335–350°F until deep gold and flaking.
  6. Stand the fillets on edge on the rack, salt them at once, and serve with the sauce and crackers.

Nutrition

Fat61 g (10 g saturated)
Sodium1180 mg
Protein35 g
Serving1 fillet with 3 tablespoons sauce
Calories812
Cholesterol120 mg
Carbohydrates34 g (4 g sugar, 2 g fiber)

Nutrition is an estimate calculated from the listed ingredients and is provided as a courtesy, not as dietary advice.

Questions readers ask

Can I shallow-fry in a skillet instead?

Yes, in about ¾ inch of oil in a heavy skillet, turning once. You will get a paler band around the edge where the fillet stood proud of the fat, and you will need to work in smaller batches to hold the temperature. The crust is the same.

What are catfish nuggets, and are they worth buying?

They are the belly flaps, cut away from the fillet by hand during processing and sold separately. They are fattier, cheaper and very good fried — treat them exactly as above and pull them a minute earlier.

Is comeback sauce the same as remoulade or Thousand Island?

Not the same, though the Mississippi Encyclopedia floats the idea that it was the Greek American answer to Thousand Island, which was the dressing of the mid-century South. Comeback has no relish and no hard-boiled egg. It is built on chili sauce and garlic, and the garlic is the part nobody in Jackson would let you cut.

Why does farm-raised catfish taste cleaner than river catfish?

Because somebody tasted it first. Mississippi State Extension describes the routine: a sample from the pond is cooked and judged by experienced tasters two weeks before harvest, the day before and the day of, and any pond that reads positive for the earthy compounds geosmin and 2-methylisoborneol is refused by the processor until it clears. Neither compound is harmful. They are simply the flavor of pond algae, and the industry built a checkpoint to keep them off the truck.