American cooking Recipes & regional stories

Skillet & Sage

A culinary journey through the fifty states

The regional table / Wyoming

Dutch-Oven Chuckwagon Beans

Published September 23, 2026 · Wyoming

Jump to Recipe

The chuckwagon is not folklore. It was a line item in a stock association's annual assessment, and the beans were what it carried.

Wyoming's round-up was an organised institution with a treasury, and the federal government wrote it down. Joseph Nimmo, Jr., Chief of the Bureau of Statistics at the Treasury Department, reported on the range and ranch cattle business of the United States on 16 May 1885, and his description of how the range was worked is exact: the stockmen "divide the country into round-up districts, in each of which there is an association, with officers and by-laws", the districts averaging some two thousand square miles, and "the members of an association make an annual contribution to pay round-up expenses, including the building of corrals and the maintenance of the round-up parties." Twice a year the parties went out — "the spring or calf round-up, and the fall or beef round-up" — and Nimmo lists what went with them: "Tents, wagons, camp equipage, and a cook are provided." The report carries an extract from the Wyoming Stock Growers' Association's own annual report for 1885 as its Appendix No. 20. The cook and his wagon were not colour; they were budgeted. The commons they worked closed within a lifetime, by statute: the grazing law now codified at 43 U.S.C. 315 authorised the Secretary of the Interior, "in order to promote the highest use of the public lands", to establish grazing districts out of "vacant, unappropriated, and unreserved lands from any part of the public domain of the United States". After that the wagon went out onto an allotment rather than an open range.

What that wagon was is in Philip Ashton Rollins's The Cowboy of 1922, which describes "chuck wagons," as mess wagons were called, taking "aboard their cooking outfits and food supplies" and rumbling out to the work place, each "made by imposing at the back end of an ordinary farm wagon a large box which contained shelves and had at its rear a lid that, hinged at the bottom and armed with legs, made, when lowered, a serviceable table." Rollins is no more sentimental about what came off it than the men were: on a drive, he writes, there was "no recreation except swearing, and the eating of the very dusty meals which the attendant chuck-wagon provided." The beans could go badly wrong, and one man said how. In The Trail Drivers of Texas, compiled by J. Marvin Hunter in 1920, the sketch headed "Trail Life," told by James Gibson of Alice, Texas, remembers a green cook set to make red beans, bacon, coffee and dried apples: "At first the coffee was all grounds, the bread like leather and the beans rattled down one's throat." That last failure has a chemical cause, it was published by the Department of Agriculture in 1900, and it is the reason this recipe starts with the water and not the beans.

Why this version works

Pork is a ration, not a garnish. The same Army manual rates the bean component against meat: beans and peas "with the right proportion of fat added in the form of bacon (about 20 per cent), are equal to meat in food value, and are a suitable substitute for fresh beef." Half a pound of slab bacon to a pound of dry beans is almost exactly that proportion, and it is what makes this a dinner rather than a side dish.

Soak, then throw the water away. The War Department's Manual for Army Cooks of 1916, written for cooking beans by the hundredweight, gives the sequence: "soaking the beans three hours, pouring off the water, scalding them in a second water which is poured off, boiling them an hour in a third water, then allowing them to simmer until done. This gives the beans a more agreeable flavor than if the water is not changed." Overnight instead of three hours is better still, and the discarded water takes a good deal of what makes beans hard company with it.

Acid at the end, never at the start. The molasses and the vinegar go in when the beans are already tender. Put them in early and the skins set; the pot then simmers for hours and gets nowhere, which is the same failure as hard water arriving by a different road. This one is not from a bulletin — it is what happens every time I have tried it the other way.

Soft water, or the beans never give in. Farmers' Bulletin 121, Beans, Peas, and Other Legumes as Food, by Mary Hinman Abel, published by the USDA in 1900, explains Gibson's rattling beans. Hard water is unsuitable "since the legumin of the seeds forms with these salts insoluble compounds with the result that portions of the vegetable remain hard, no matter how long they are cooked." The bulletin cites lentils boiled the same length of time in distilled and in limed water: the first cooked soft in an hour and a half, the second came out with only the skins swollen "over the kernel, which remained entirely hard." On the range the water came out of alkali creeks. In a kitchen, use filtered or bottled water and the problem disappears.

Ingredient notes

Pork: eight ounces of slab bacon or salt pork, cut in half-inch dice with the rind left on. If you use salt pork, rinse it and hold the added salt back until the end, because it carries a great deal of its own.

Beans: a pound of pinto beans. Gibson's cook was told to make "red beans," and pinto is what the country ran on; small red beans or bayos behave the same way. Old beans are the other cause of a pot that will not soften, and there is no way to tell their age by looking, so buy from somewhere that sells a lot of them.

Chile: two dried anchos or New Mexico pods, stemmed, seeded and torn up, or two tablespoons of plain chili powder. They soften into the liquid over three hours and colour the whole pot. This is not chili — the chile here is a background, not the subject.

Water: six cups, and this is the ingredient that decides the recipe. Filtered or bottled if your tap is hard. Boiling hard water and pouring it off the sediment first, as Bulletin 121 advises, helps where the hardness is carbonate, and does nothing at all where it is sulphate of lime or magnesia.

Step by step

  1. Soak overnight. Cover the beans with cold water by three inches and leave them 8 to 12 hours. Drain and discard that water.
  2. Scald and drain again. Cover the drained beans with fresh water, bring to the boil, hold it for 2 minutes, and pour that water off too. Two changes is what the Army manual asks for and it is worth the four minutes.
  3. Render the pork. Heat the oven to 300°F. Cook the diced bacon in a 5-quart Dutch oven over medium heat for 8 minutes, until the fat runs and the edges brown. Add the onion and cook 6 minutes more, until it is limp and translucent.
  4. Build the pot. Stir in the garlic, the torn chile and the black pepper and cook 1 minute. Add the beans, the bay and 6 cups of soft water. Bring to a boil, skim the foam, and put the lid on.
  5. Into the oven. Bake covered 2 hours 30 minutes. Check at 2 hours: the liquid should sit about half an inch above the beans and blip slowly, not boil. Add half a cup of hot water if it has dropped below them.
  6. Finish with sugar, salt and acid. When a bean crushes to paste between finger and thumb, stir in the molasses, the salt and the vinegar. Uncovered, back in the oven for 20 to 30 minutes, until the liquid has pulled in around the beans.
  7. Let it settle. Off the heat 20 minutes before serving. The broth thickens as it cools and goes on thickening overnight.
Beans still hard after three hours are almost always a water problem or an age problem, and neither is fixed by more time. Drain off the cooking liquid, cover them with boiling bottled water and an eighth of a teaspoon of baking soda, and give them another 45 minutes — the soda works where the hardness is carbonate, and Bulletin 121 warns that it costs you some flavour, which is why it is a rescue and not a method. If the pot is soupy at the end, lift the lid and bake on; if it has gone dry and the beans are catching, add hot water half a cup at a time and never cold.

Storage and make-ahead

Five days in the fridge, and better on day two — the skins relax and the broth sets to a loose gel that loosens again over heat.

It freezes for 3 months. Freeze it slightly wetter than you want it, because reheating always tightens it.

What to serve with it

The sourdough biscuits on this site, which came off the same wagon, or cornbread. Something is needed to get the broth out of the bowl.

Raw onion and pickled jalapeños on the side. Three hours of pork and chile wants something sharp and uncooked next to it.

From the recipe box / Wyoming

Dutch-Oven Chuckwagon Beans

A pound of pinto beans soaked overnight, thrown into fresh water with salt pork and dried chile, and left in a low oven under a lid until the pot liquor thickens by itself.

Prep
25 min, plus overnight soaking
Cook
3 hr 10 min
Total
3 hr 35 min, plus overnight soaking
Serves
8
Calories
335 per serving

Ingredients

Scale

Instructions

  1. Soak the beans in cold water 8–12 hours, then drain and discard the water.
  2. Cover with fresh water, boil 2 minutes, and drain again.
  3. Heat the oven to 300°F. Render the bacon 8 minutes in a 5-quart Dutch oven, then soften the onion 6 minutes.
  4. Add the garlic, chile and pepper, cook 1 minute, then add the beans, bay and 6 cups of water. Boil, skim, cover.
  5. Bake covered 2 hours 30 minutes, topping up with hot water if the level drops below the beans.
  6. Stir in the molasses, salt and vinegar and bake uncovered 20–30 minutes more.
  7. Rest 20 minutes off the heat before serving.

Nutrition

Fat13 g (4 g saturated)
Sodium850 mg
Protein15 g
Servingabout 1 cup
Calories335
Cholesterol20 mg
Carbohydrates41 g (5 g sugar, 9 g fiber)

Nutrition is an estimate calculated from the listed ingredients and is provided as a courtesy, not as dietary advice.

Questions readers ask

Do I really have to soak them?

You can skip it and cook them an hour longer, but you lose the two water changes, and those are the part the Army manual says is worth doing: three waters give the beans "a more agreeable flavor than if the water is not changed". The soak is also your best defence against a pot that never softens, because most of the calcium that causes that comes in with the water rather than the beans.

Can I cook this on a real fire?

Yes, and the 1916 Army manual describes the field version: beans baked "in dugout ovens, clay ovens, or a vertical hole dug in the ground into which a jar or camp kettle containing them is placed and packed over and around with hot coals and earth." What you lose is the thermostat, and with it any way of knowing that you are at 300°F rather than 400°F. Coals on the lid and few underneath is the nearest a fire gets to a low oven.

Is this the authentic chuckwagon recipe?

There is no such document, and anyone who shows you one has made it up. What the record gives is the outfit and the ration: a cook and a wagon paid for out of association dues in Nimmo's 1885 report, and red beans, bacon, coffee and dried fruit in the trail drivers' own accounts. The quantities and the timings on this page were worked out for this page, from those ingredients, by me.

My beans stayed hard for hours. What went wrong?

Hard water or old beans. USDA Farmers' Bulletin 121 of 1900 is blunt about the first: with lime and magnesia salts in the water, the seeds form insoluble compounds and "portions of the vegetable remain hard, no matter how long they are cooked." Boiling the water first and pouring it off the sediment fixes carbonate hardness; nothing in your kitchen fixes sulphate hardness, so use bottled water and move on.