American cooking Recipes & regional stories

Skillet & Sage

A culinary journey through the fifty states

The regional table / Ohio

Goetta

Published September 22, 2026 · Ohio

Jump to Recipe

The oat is the whole argument. Take it out and put corn meal in and you have scrapple, which is a Pennsylvania dish; leave it in and you have the breakfast of a German pork town.

Cincinnati was a hog city before it was anything else, and the numbers are in a book you can open. Charles Cist's Sketches and Statistics of Cincinnati in 1851 gives the trade a chapter of its own, headed The Hog and its Products. Pork, he writes, is our great staple, and hogs to the number of four hundred and ninety-eight thousand one hundred and sixty have been cut up in the market in a single year. The season ran from November to March. There were ten slaughter houses on the edge of town, fifty feet by a hundred and thirty, boarded with movable lattice that was kept open for the air; the blood ran into tanks and was sold to the makers of prussian blue; and at the end of the line a man called the gutter worked, Cist says, at the rate of three hogs to the minute. The same book counts the city's foreigners by birthplace and puts Germany at the head of the list with 30,628, far ahead of Ireland's 13,616. A German city and a pig city in the same square mile is the whole explanation of goetta, and neither half of it has to be guessed at.

The grain is documented too, if from an odd angle. USDA Farmers' Bulletin 420, Oats: Distribution and Uses, by C. W. Warburton of the Bureau of Plant Industry, issued in November 1910, notes that most of the oatmeal then manufactured was more properly termed rolled oats, though the cracked or cut grain, commonly known as groats, was still used to a limited extent — and that long cooking not only makes it more palatable but greatly increases its digestibility. That cut grain, sold now as steel-cut or pinhead oats, is what goetta is built on, and the bulletin is telling you in 1910 both that it had already become the minority product and exactly how to treat it. The German word for it is Grütze, which an 1882 German-English dictionary glosses as groats, grit, and traces to an old verb meaning to grind. What is not documented anywhere I could reach is the word goetta itself. It is in none of the Ohio cookbooks that are old enough to be public domain — not in Buckeye Cookery of 1877, not in the Christ Hospital Cook Book printed in Cincinnati in 1914 by the hospital's own dietitian — and an exact-phrase search of Ohio Memory, the Ohio History Connection and State Library of Ohio programme with a million pages of newspaper text behind it, returns thirty-three pages, the earliest dated 12 October 1961, in a Warren County weekly whose run there begins in 1807. Ohio Memory does not carry the Cincinnati dailies and loc.gov refuses scripts, so that is a hole in the record rather than proof of anything. What the old Ohio book does carry is the rival: Buckeye Cookery prints a scrapple made from a boiled pig's head, chopped fine, returned to its skimmed liquor and thickened with corn meal till of the consistency of soft mush, then poured into pans, set in a cool place and sliced and fried for breakfast in winter. That is goetta's architecture exactly, with the wrong grain in it.

Why this version works

Overnight in the pan. Warm goetta cannot be sliced and will not crust; it spreads and steams. A night in the fridge sets the gelatin and lets the whole loaf dry slightly at the surface, and a dry surface is the only kind that browns.

Pinhead oats, not rolled. Steel-cut oats are the whole groat chopped into two or three pieces, so the starch is locked inside a grain that holds its shape for hours. That is what gives set goetta a sliceable body with texture still in it. Rolled oats are steamed and flattened, dump their starch in twenty minutes and set into a smooth paste that collapses in the pan.

Three hours on the lowest heat. This is Warburton's point from 1910 about long cooking, and it is also the difference between goetta and porridge with meat in it. The grains have to give up enough starch to bind the meat but keep enough structure to stop the slice turning to mush over the heat.

The oats cook in the pork broth. Every bit of gelatin and rendered fat from the shoulder goes into the grain rather than down the drain. The gelatin is what makes a cold loaf firm enough to cut half an inch thick and carry to a hot skillet without breaking, and the fat is what lets the cut face brown.

Ingredient notes

Oats: steel-cut, pinhead or Irish oats — three names for the same cut grain. Rolled oats, quick oats and instant oats will all fail, and oat flour fails worst. Buy them plain; the ones sold as steel-cut porridge mixes have salt and milk powder in them.

Pork: boneless shoulder, sometimes sold as Boston butt, with the fat left on it. Loin and leg are too lean to hold up to three hours of simmering and give a loaf that tastes like oatmeal. Cincinnati versions are commonly half pork and half beef chuck, and the recipe takes that swap without any other change.

Aromatics: onion, bay and allspice, and very little else. Goetta is a plain loaf that gets its interest from the pork and the crust, and a long list of spices in the pot reads as confusion after three hours. Save the black pepper for the end so it does not go dull.

Fat for frying: lard if you have it, bacon fat if you do not, and a thin film of it rather than a pool. Butter burns before the crust forms at the temperature this needs, and a dry non-stick pan gives you a pale slice with no edge to it.

Step by step

  1. Simmer the pork. Put the pork, the halved onion, the bay leaves and half the salt in a large pot with 8 cups of cold water. Bring it barely to a simmer and hold it there, uncovered, about 2 hours, until the meat falls apart under a fork. Skim the foam in the first ten minutes.
  2. Separate meat and broth. Lift the meat out and strain the broth, discarding the onion and bay. Measure the broth and make it up to 6 cups with water. Shred the pork with two forks, then chop it fine — coarser than a paste, finer than pulled pork.
  3. Cook the oats. Bring the 6 cups of broth back to a boil, rain in the oats while stirring, then drop the heat as low as it goes. Cook 2 hours uncovered, stirring every fifteen minutes and scraping the bottom, until the grains are soft but still distinct and a spoon dragged across the pot leaves a track.
  4. Put the pork back. Stir in the chopped pork, the remaining salt, the pepper, the allspice and the nutmeg. Cook another 30 minutes on the same low heat, stirring more often now that it is thick. It is ready when a wooden spoon stands up in it for a second before falling.
  5. Set it overnight. Pack the hot mixture into two 8-by-4-inch loaf pans lined with plastic wrap or parchment, press the top flat, and cool it on the counter for an hour before refrigerating overnight. It must be cold all the way through and firm to the thumb before it is cut.
  6. Fry the slices. Turn a loaf out and cut it into half-inch slices. Heat the lard in a cast iron skillet over medium, lay the slices in without crowding, and then leave them alone for 8 to 10 minutes. Turn once, fry another 8 minutes, and serve immediately with both faces crusted almost black.
If the slices fall apart as they cook, the loaf was short of gelatin or the oats were undercooked; scoop the pieces together into a patty with a spatula, press down, and let it set into a rough cake rather than fighting it. Next time add a split pig's trotter to the simmering pork. If the crust never forms, the pan was not hot enough or the slices were moved too soon — raise the heat, wait, and accept that the first two slices of any batch are a test. A loaf that is too soft to cut at all can be spooned into the skillet and fried as hash, which is what a Cincinnati kitchen does with the end of the pan anyway.

Storage and make-ahead

The uncut loaf keeps 5 days wrapped in the fridge and slices better on day three than on day one. Fried slices do not keep — they go leathery within the hour and rubbery overnight — so fry only what is going on the plate.

Goetta freezes well in slices. Freeze them separated by parchment on a tray, bag them once solid, and fry them straight from frozen over slightly lower heat for about 12 minutes a side.

What to serve with it

Two fried eggs and toast, which is what it is for. The runny yolk does the job that gravy does elsewhere, and there should be nothing else on the plate competing with it.

For a plate later in the day, goetta takes strong mustard, apple sauce or a spoonful of apple butter — the sharpness cuts three hours of pork fat better than anything sweet on its own.

From the recipe box / Ohio

Goetta

Cincinnati's pork and pinhead-oat loaf: shoulder simmered to threads, oats cooked three hours in the same broth, set overnight in a pan and fried in slices until both faces are black-brown and brittle.

Prep
20 min
Cook
4 hr 30 min
Total
4 hr 50 min, plus overnight chilling
Serves
8
Calories
425 per serving

Ingredients

Scale

Instructions

  1. Simmer the pork with the water, onion, bay and half the salt about 2 hours, until it falls apart under a fork.
  2. Strain, make the broth up to 6 cups, and chop the shredded pork fine.
  3. Boil the broth, rain in the oats, and cook 2 hours on the lowest heat, stirring and scraping every 15 minutes.
  4. Stir in the pork, the rest of the salt, the pepper, allspice and nutmeg, and cook 30 minutes more until a spoon stands in it.
  5. Pack into two lined 8-by-4-inch loaf pans, cool, and refrigerate overnight until firm.
  6. Cut half-inch slices and fry in lard over medium, 8–10 minutes a side, undisturbed, until both faces are crusted dark.

Nutrition

Fat22 g (7 g saturated)
Sodium950 mg
Protein26 g
Servingtwo fried slices
Calories425
Cholesterol85 mg
Carbohydrates27 g (1 g sugar, 4 g fiber)

Nutrition is an estimate calculated from the listed ingredients and is provided as a courtesy, not as dietary advice.

Questions readers ask

Can I use rolled oats?

No, and this is the one substitution that cannot be worked around. Rolled oats are steamed and pressed flat, which is a head start on cooking you do not want here; they release all their starch early, thicken to wallpaper paste in twenty minutes and set into a loaf that slumps in the pan instead of crusting. If only rolled oats are in the house, make something else today.

Why is my goetta grey?

Because it is boiled pork and oats, and that is the colour they are. Goetta is a pale dish before it meets the skillet and the whole of its appeal is the crust, which is why it wants a long, patient fry and not a quick turn. If you want colour in the loaf itself, use half beef chuck, which cooks darker than pork.

How long can it sit before frying?

It has to sit at least eight hours to be sliceable, and it is happier after two days. Five days wrapped in the fridge is the outer limit for the uncut loaf, and after that freeze it in slices with parchment between them and fry them from frozen.

Is goetta the same thing as scrapple?

Same idea, different grain, and the grain changes the dish. Buckeye Cookery, printed in Ohio in 1877, gives a scrapple of boiled pig's head chopped fine and thickened with corn meal to the consistency of soft mush, then poured into pans and fried in slices for winter breakfasts. Corn meal sets hard and fries to a smooth, slightly gritty slab. Steel-cut oats set softer and stay visible, so goetta fries with a rough, nubbled face and a creamier middle.